Table of contents
If you’re wondering what a personal injury case might actually pay, the numbers vary widely, but many settlements fall between $15,000 and $75,000, depending on the injury. In Florida, minor soft tissue injuries might settle for as little as $6,000 to $10,000, while more serious cases, such as broken bones or long-term impairments, can reach $50,000 to over $150,000. Catastrophic injuries or wrongful death claims may result in six- or even seven-figure payouts, especially when economic and non-economic damages are fully considered. But behind every number is a complex process with many factors that influence your final amount, and we’ll break those down for you in this article.
Factors Influencing Settlement Amounts
Many clients ask their attorneys, “How much is the average personal injury settlement?” The answer depends on the severity of the plaintiff’s injuries. Severity doesn’t depend on your hospital stay or physical pain alone. Other factors can influence the settlement outcome.
Injury Severity
Many personal injury settlements use a tier list to determine injury severity:
- Tier one: You have a permanent disfigurement or disability from your injuries. You might have sustained traumatic brain injuries, spinal trauma, or a cosmetic defect.
- Tier two: You broke a bone or sustained a deep laceration. These injuries may occur due to forceful impacts from a vehicle or machinery misuse and malfunction.
- Tier three: Your injuries might temporarily impact your range of motion and ability to work. For example, sprains, bruises, and muscle strains might prevent you from going about your typical routine.
The defendants will present a potential settlement amount based on these tiers.
The Influence of Pain and Suffering
As mentioned, other influences beyond the noticeable injury itself can help you negotiate a higher settlement. This is when your legal team comes in to advocate for these concerns. Pain and suffering refer to the physical, mental, and emotional harm your injury may have incurred.
For example, you survived a sudden, traumatic car accident. You might have nightmares or exhibit other symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder in the wake of the wreck. These symptoms prevent you from enjoying much-needed rest and worsen your mental state.
You might also need more medical services in the following months and years. Who will cover these costs if the potential settlement only accounts for your immediate needs?
Economic vs. Non-Economic Damage
Accounting for the influence of pain and suffering means calculating the costs of economic and non-economic damage:
- Economic damages include medical bills, rehab, lost wages, future treatment costs, and out-of-pocket expenses.
- Non-economic damages include emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, social withdrawal, and damage to your reputation or relationships.
These are harder to quantify but often represent the true long-term impact of an injury.
Insurance Policy and Coverage Limitation
Even if your damages are severe, your settlement might be limited by the at-fault party’s insurance policy. For example, in a car accident, if the at-fault driver’s policy only covers $50,000, that may be the maximum amount you can recover in settlement from their insurer, even if your actual losses are higher. In such cases, your legal team may explore other options, like holding additional parties liable or pursuing underinsured motorist coverage through your own policy to help close the gap.
Liability Disputes and Shared Fault
Florida follows a modified comparative negligence rule (since March 2023): if you’re more than 50% at fault, you cannot recover damages. If you’re less than 50% at fault, your compensation is reduced accordingly. So proving fault clearly and early can significantly boost your chances of a better settlement.
Quality of Evidence
The strength of your case hinges on your documentation. Photos, witness statements, medical records, work absence logs, and psychological evaluations can all increase your settlement value. Weak evidence can undermine even serious claims.
How Settlements Vary by Jurisdiction
The location at which the accident occurred will also impact your settlement amount. Some jurisdictions lean heavily in favor of the injured party, no matter who is at fault. Other areas divide accountability by percentage. The defendant and their insurance provider might be more willing to provide a generous settlement if the accident happened in the former.
Average Settlement Amounts by Injury Types
The average settlement for your personal injury depends on the tier, the economic damages you must pay for, and the non-economic problems that developed because of your injury.
| Tier / Case Type | Examples of Injuries | Estimated Settlement Range |
| Wrongful Death | Fatal injuries due to car accidents, truck collisions, or workplace incidents | Up to $2,000,000+ |
| Tier One | Permanent disability, traumatic brain injury (TBI), spinal cord damage, amputation, severe burns, disfigurement | $150,000 – $1,000,000+ |
| Tier Two | Broken bones, deep lacerations, internal injuries, concussions, herniated discs | $40,000 – $100,000 |
| Tier Three | Sprains, whiplash, muscle strains, minor head trauma, temporary mobility loss | $15,000 – $35,000 |
| No Diagnosed Injury | Soft tissue discomfort, psychological trauma without documented physical injury | Up to $6,000 – $10,000 |
The fault level also influences whether the defendants in your case opt to settle before a trial. The Law Dictionary asserts that many personal injury cases settle before a trial takes place. As long as the majority of the fault lies with the defendant, the plaintiff has a reasonable chance of taking a settlement home, especially with guidance from a seasoned attorney.
These figures are general estimates. The actual value of a personal injury settlement depends heavily on the specific details of your case, including injury severity, fault, available insurance coverage, medical documentation, and even where the accident occurred. No two cases are the same, so speaking with an experienced attorney is the best way to understand what your claim might be worth.
Maximizing Your Settlement Amount
If you and your attorney have determined a settlement is a realistic goal, you will work together to secure the highest possible amount. You need ample evidence to do this. Ideally, you begin documenting the injury as soon as the event occurs.
The documentation provides a timeline of events, the conditions surrounding the injury, and the damage the event caused. You can gather evidence by:
- Taking photos: Photographs show the injury’s severity and are essential immediately after it happens. You can also document the healing time with photos.
- Saving medical bills: Organize copies of your medical bills to show the expenses required to heal from the injury. This includes emergency room visits and subsequent checkups with your medical team.
- Keeping correspondence between you and your doctor: Take screenshots of emails or text conversations between you and your care and insurance providers. Put prescriptions, recommendations, diagnoses, and imaging scans in a folder together.
- Documenting your personal struggles following the injury: If you struggle with mental health symptoms or social concerns, maintain a diary of these experiences.
- Saving communications between you and your employer: You might take days off from work to recover. Document the wages you’ve lost as a product of the injury.
Your lawyer can use these documents and access other evidentiary sources, like witness reports and camera footage, to compile a convincing trail of proof.
Why Lawyering Up Is Essential
Attempting to navigate a settlement on your own could mean the defendants shortchange you on the final amount. Even though they don’t involve a judge’s verdict, personal injury settlements work similarly to court cases. They require specific types of evidence, knowledge of the legal system, and an understanding of terms and definitions surrounding settlements.
Plus, you don’t need the added stress of negotiating with the defendant’s insurance provider. Remember: their job focuses on protecting themselves and their profits from cases like these. You need a lawyer at the helm of your case who understands the terms and tactics used to avoid high settlement payouts.
Negotiating With the Insurance Companies
When negotiations for your personal injury settlement begin, the following tips might prove helpful in securing a generous amount. Although your attorney will likely apply these rules, knowing them for yourself can ensure you understand what is going on and which direction your settlement case may take:
- Trace the injury or condition directly to the defendant. The defendant’s insurance provider needs to see that you can specifically identify the defendant as the cause of your injury.
- Identify the cause. Be as specific as possible when naming the cause. For example, a car wreck injury settlement should outline the defendant’s speed, impact force, and environmental circumstances.
- Don’t take the initial offer. The insurance company may attempt to lowball you at first.
- Highlight your emotional struggles. Many clients focus more on the physical ramifications of their injury. Your lawyer should emphasize the significance of your emotional damages, too.
- Keep all offers and correspondence in writing or another recording medium. Detailed notes and signed agreements help set the settlement in stone.
- Make a high counteroffer and negotiate down from it. Your lawyer should have a specific settlement amount in mind before the negotiations. Their counteroffer should be higher than the preferred amount so that the defendant must haggle down.
When To Accept a Settlement Offer
As you work with your lawyer, they will likely determine when you can accept an offer by:
- Ensuring the amount covers all issues caused by the injury: Your attorney will calculate the potential cost of economic and non-economic damages and counteroffer a higher amount to work down from.
- Waiting for longer periods to achieve higher settlements: As mentioned, you should never take the first offer. Waiting can yield higher payouts.
- Potentially threatening a lawsuit: Your lawyer may still threaten to take the defendant to court. This tactic could help them acquire a higher settlement amount.
What might seem like a considerable settlement to you might actually shortchange you and leave you vulnerable later. Let your legal team navigate negotiations to protect you now and in the future.
Real Case Examples: What Personal Injury Settlements Can Look Like
At Steinger, Greene & Feiner, we’ve handled thousands of personal injury cases across Florida, and our results highlight how settlement amounts can vary based on the type and severity of the injury. Here are a few examples of what we’ve recovered for our clients:
- Auto Accidents: $1.5 million for a client hit by a driver entering oncoming traffic, and $750,000 for a rear-end crash while stopped in traffic.
- Slip & Fall: $1 million for a client injured by a falling commercial shelf, and another $1 million for a fall at an indoor trampoline park.
- Truck Accidents: $800,000 for a highway rear-end collision with an 18-wheeler, and $467,000 for a semi-truck wrongful death case.
- Rideshare & Scooter Accidents: $1 million for a rideshare passenger struck by another car, and $100,000 for a scooter rider hit by a vehicle exiting a parking lot.
These examples show the range of compensation possible—and the importance of working with a legal team that knows how to build a strong case.
Contact a Personal Injury Lawyer for Help With Personal Injury Settlements
The average personal injury settlement varies based on location, injury severity, and the fallout you experience as a consequence. At Steinger, Greene & Feiner, our Florida personal injury lawyers will work tirelessly to help you negotiate a fair settlement amount. Contact us to book a free consultation.
Our team practices in numerous states and counsels clients with diverse personal injury concerns.